This page has been updated. Go to Daily Info's beautiful new review page here:

www.dailyinfo.co.uk/reviews/venue/195/The+Old+Parsonage+Hotel/

If you are not redirected automatically within a few seconds then please click on the link above.

The Old Parsonage Hotel & Restaurant, 1 Banbury Road, Oxford OX2 6NN. Tel: 01865 310210. Menu here
[email protected]

Reviewed
July 2004

On a mild Tuesday evening, the outdoor dining area of the Old Parsonage looked a picture. White canvas umbrellas, the first barbecue of the season sizzling away in the corner under the watchful eye of the head chef, hardly an empty table and no one in a hurry - what more can one ask of a summer evening's dining?

After drinks in the bar adjoining the ridiculously opulent indoor dining area (the walls adorned with so many pieces of art that it would have taken at least another hour to look at them all), we were escorted to our table (it having been left to us to decide whether to eat outdoors or in). The most noticeable feature at this stage, and that which characterized the whole affair, was the quality of the service. Extremely attentive - as you might expect from a fairly small restaurant with a relatively high per person spend - and genuinely cheerful; our waitress evidently knew her stuff.

To start, we chose two appetizers to share: black olive tapenade with crostini and a half dozen quail eggs with celery salt. Quail eggs are always a rather silly treat, being only normal eggs in a prettier, bite-size portion - but as such there were certainly no complaints, only the celery salt being remarkable (in that it came in the form of large brown flakes). I was less fond of the tapenade, but then, I didn't have to eat it all!

To start (yes, we really did have appetizers as well as starters, main courses and desserts) we shared a half lobster, and this was excellent. Being a vegetarian (an increasingly bad one), I have only eaten lobster on a handful of occasions, and shied away slightly from the business of claw-cracking - which is evidently fun if you like that kind of thing. It was certainly the best of the few lobsters I have eaten, and, like everything else, beautifully presented.

My main course was a shredded free-range chicken salad with baby spinach, almonds, basil, quail eggs (can't get enough of those little speckled things) and mustard, and was the gourmet equivalent of a bowl of crunchy-nut cornflakes - I could have eaten another whole one, but I would have exploded. It was delicious. My friend had a lamb brochette and cous-cous with which she was mightily pleased, declaring it to be very well cooked and interesting (not always easy with lamb). Both the lobster and the lamb were chosen from the Parsonage's Grill menu, which has been added to their regular list for the summer. This is quite fun, as not only do you get a greater choice of lovely things to eat, but you can also watch the chef at work. Live jazz will also be on offer on Friday evenings, which should really add to the atmosphere.

Attempting to stuff myself to the max, I finished the whole experience with a crème brulée, which was (I'm afraid to say) a little disappointing. Perhaps it was just that this was the last straw in terms of stomach capacity, or perhaps it just wasn't cooked quite enough, but this did taste like excessively sugary set custard (something I am informed that the correct cooking process should trick you into thinking you are not eating). My friend had a tarte tatin, which she found delicious, although, she said, purists might miss the slight bitterness that it can sometimes have.

The crème brulée aside, I was extremely impressed with the Old Parsonage, which formerly I had not even really known to possess a restaurant open to the public. Presented at last with a bill for two for around £70, which incidentally included 2 glasses of white wine (the cheapest glass on offer - a chenin blanc at £3.80 - and the most expensive, a semillion at £5.95 - the price difference being reflected clearly in the quality) and a bottle and a half of sparkling mineral water, I was shocked at how reasonable the whole thing had been. Proper vegetarians should bear in mind that there are only two main courses for them - the Caesar salad and the spaghettini, both weighing in at around the £10 mark. The menu is quite restricted, but I suspect that no dish on it offers much of weak point for criticism. All in all, the Old Parsonage seems to offer an opportunity for relaxed fine dining on a less scary budget than would usually be required for the quality of goods you receive. Their produce is of very high quality, with fresh fish flown in straight from the Channel Islands and beef from a specialist butcher. The service is of a very high standard but relaxed and un-intimidating, and the setting is really lovely. What better way to while away two and a half hours of a summer evening?

Su Jordan / Susie Cogan