Stage Beauty (15), dir. Richard Eyre, 2004

In 1660s London theatre, women were forbidden to perform on the stage. Stage Beauty tells the story of drag actor Ned Kynaston (Billy Crudup), described by Samuel Pepys as 'the most beautiful woman on the stage', whose life collapses when real women are allowed to compete.

The drama centres around Kynaston's relationship with Maria (Clare Danes), who begins the film as his dresser, but whose dreams of becoming an actress set his downfall in motion.

The story has obvious echoes of Shakespeare In Love, and retains that film's combination of broad humour and theatrical melodrama. The production design is similarly impressive, although budget limitations are occasionally obvious - Charles II's decadent court appears to be a small maisonette.

The film jumps between characters and plots, and fails to properly develop any of them. We see Maria trying to become an actress, but even she admits that she's dreadful, so it's not clear why we should be rooting for her.

As Kynaston loses his celebrity, he becomes unsure of his own gender, but this too is unconvincing; isn't he just depressed about not being famous anymore?

This lack of dramatic focus leads to mixed performances. Crudup is convincingly androgynous, but Danes spends the film impersonating Gwyneth Paltrow. Rupert Everett and newcomer Zoë Tapper have the most fun, going gloriously over the top as Charles II and Nell Gwyn.

David Haviland 01.09.04